NISTAML.036 · Leaking Information from User Interactions
Explore 3 source-supported AI security cases for NISTAML.036 · Leaking Information from User Interactions in NIST Adversarial ML (2025), with evidence, scope, and defensive analysis.
Risk category
An attacker indirectly instructs a model to obtain information from a user during an interaction and then leak it. The model may persuade the user to provide a detail and send it to an attacker-controlled URL, suggest that the user visit that URL, or expose it through an externally loaded image. The information is collected through the user interaction, rather than only copied from an already connected private resource.
Embrace the Red (https://embracethered.com/blog/) demonstrated that Bard users' conversations could be exfiltrated via an indirect prompt injection. To execute the attack, a threat actor shares a Google Doc containing the prompt with the target user who then interacts with the document via Bard to inadvertently execute the prompt. The prompt causes Bard to respond with the markdown for an image, whose URL has the user's conversation secretly embedded. Bard renders the image for the user, creating an automatic request to an adversary-controlled script and exfiltrating the user's conversation. The request is not blocked by Google's Content Security Policy (CSP), because the script is hosted as a Google Apps Script with a Google-owned domain. Note: Google has fixed this vulnerability. The CSP remains the same, and Bard can still render images for the user, so there may be some filtering of data embedded in URLs.
Why it relates: Embrace the Red (https://embracethered.com/blog/) demonstrated that Bard users' conversations could be exfiltrated via an indirect prompt injection. The relevant category is Leaking Information from User Interactions: An attacker indirectly instructs a model to obtain information from a user during an interaction and then leak it.
Embrace the Red (https://embracethered.com/blog/) demonstrated that Bard users' conversations could be exfiltrated via an indirect prompt injection. To execute the attack, a threat actor shares a Google Doc containing the prompt with the target user who then interacts with the document via Bard to inadvertently execute the prompt. The prompt causes Bard to respond with the markdown for an image, whose URL has the user's conversation secretly embedded. Bard renders the image for the user, creating an automatic request to an adversary-controlled script and exfiltrating the user's conversation. The request is not blocked by Google's Content Security Policy (CSP), because the script is hosted as a Google Apps Script with a Google-owned domain. Note: Google has fixed this vulnerability. The CSP remains the same, and Bard can still render images for the user, so there may be some filtering of data embedded in URLs.
Embrace the Red (https://embracethered.com/blog/) demonstrated that ChatGPT users' conversations can be exfiltrated via an indirect prompt injection. To execute the attack, a threat actor uploads a malicious prompt to a public website, where a ChatGPT user may interact with it. The prompt causes ChatGPT to respond with the markdown for an image, whose URL has the user's conversation secretly embedded. ChatGPT renders the image for the user, creating an automatic request to an adversary-controlled script and exfiltrating the user's conversation. Additionally, the researcher demonstrated how the prompt can execute other plugins, opening them up to additional harms.
Why it relates: Embrace the Red (https://embracethered.com/blog/) demonstrated that ChatGPT users' conversations can be exfiltrated via an indirect prompt injection. The relevant category is Leaking Information from User Interactions: An attacker indirectly instructs a model to obtain information from a user during an interaction and then leak it.
Embrace the Red (https://embracethered.com/blog/) demonstrated that ChatGPT users' conversations can be exfiltrated via an indirect prompt injection. To execute the attack, a threat actor uploads a malicious prompt to a public website, where a ChatGPT user may interact with it. The prompt causes ChatGPT to respond with the markdown for an image, whose URL has the user's conversation secretly embedded. ChatGPT renders the image for the user, creating an automatic request to an adversary-controlled script and exfiltrating the user's conversation. Additionally, the researcher demonstrated how the prompt can execute other plugins, opening them up to additional harms.
Whenever interacting with Microsoft's new Bing Chat LLM Chatbot, a user can allow Bing Chat permission to view and access currently open websites throughout the chat session. Researchers demonstrated the ability for an attacker to plant an injection in a website the user is visiting, which silently turns Bing Chat into a Social Engineer who seeks out and exfiltrates personal information. The user doesn't have to ask about the website or do anything except interact with Bing Chat while the website is opened in the browser in order for this attack to be executed. In the provided demonstration, a user opened a prepared malicious website containing an indirect prompt injection attack (could also be on a social media site) in Edge. The website includes a prompt which is read by Bing and changes its behavior to access user information, which in turn can sent to an attacker.
Why it relates: Whenever interacting with Microsoft's new Bing Chat LLM Chatbot, a user can allow Bing Chat permission to view and access currently open websites throughout the chat session. The relevant category is Leaking Information from User Interactions: An attacker indirectly instructs a model to obtain information from a user during an interaction and then leak it.
Whenever interacting with Microsoft's new Bing Chat LLM Chatbot, a user can allow Bing Chat permission to view and access currently open websites throughout the chat session. Researchers demonstrated the ability for an attacker to plant an injection in a website the user is visiting, which silently turns Bing Chat into a Social Engineer who seeks out and exfiltrates personal information. The user doesn't have to ask about the website or do anything except interact with Bing Chat while the website is opened in the browser in order for this attack to be executed. In the provided demonstration, a user opened a prepared malicious website containing an indirect prompt injection attack (could also be on a social media site) in Edge. The website includes a prompt which is read by Bing and changes its behavior to access user information, which in turn can sent to an attacker.